Okay so theres a girl i used to like alot she made me wait a long time to get into a relationship but it never?

It never happened so i moved on and had with this new girl and fell inlove but now the otger girl wants me, i go to school with one and the other lives an hour away.. I always think about trust and everything but i just couldnt deal with hurting the one i did stuff with.. Should i go for tge girl that made me wait a long time and hurt me or the one that maybe someday can hurt me badly